Menu

The Paradox of Plenty

We are the most comfortable humans who have ever lived, and among the most unwell. Warm water runs from the tap. Food arrives at the door. A library of the world’s knowledge sits in a pocket. And still the waiting rooms fill: anxiety, insomnia, burnout, chronic pain that no scan can explain, a loneliness that public health officials now speak of as an epidemic.

This is not a coincidence. Something in the way we hold our abundance is making us sick. I want to name it plainly: privilege without gratitude. Not privilege alone, and not a lack of thank-you notes. I mean the quiet, unexamined assumption that what we have is simply the baseline, and that what we lack is the problem.

But I also want to be careful. Because the cure that gets sold for this, “just be more grateful,” can be its own kind of poison. So this is an blog about holding two truths at once.

Seeing privilege clearly

Privilege is not a moral accusation. It is a description of where you stand in a system you did not design. A passport that opens borders. Clean air. Healthcare you can reach. Time to sit on a mat and contemplate your breath. Much of what makes Western comfort possible is produced elsewhere, by hands we never see. The phone is mined in the Congo, the clothes stitched in Dhaka, the coffee picked in the highlands of Ethiopia or Benguet. Care work itself is outsourced: Filipino nurses and caregivers hold up health systems across Europe while their own children grow up over video calls. When we fail to see this web, two things happen. Our comfort becomes invisible to us, so it stops nourishing us. And the people who carry its cost become invisible too. Unseen privilege is not neutral. It numbs the one who has it and erases the one who pays for it.

Against compulsory gratitude

And yet. I am suspicious of the gratitude industry: the journals, the affirmation cards, the wellness posts that tell us to count our blessings before breakfast. Gratitude sold this way often becomes a sedative. It asks us to feel good about a world that is not good for most people in it. There is a shadow version of gratitude that goes like this: I am blessed, therefore I need not ask why others are not. That is spiritual bypassing with a nicer font. It turns privilege into proof of virtue, and suffering into someone else’s lack of positive thinking. And gratitude is weaponised downward, too. Workers are told to be grateful for a job. Migrants are told to be grateful for being let in. Women are told to be grateful for being allowed in the room. Gratitude demanded from those with less is not a spiritual practice. It is a tool of silence.

So no, the answer to privilege without gratitude is not more performance of gratitude. It is something deeper.

Santosha and the illusion of lack

Patanjali lists santosha, contentment, among the niyamas, and promises that from it comes unsurpassed happiness. But santosha is not resignation, and it is not a mood you manufacture. In the light of Advaita Vedanta, it is what remains when the false sense of lack falls away. Vedanta’s diagnosis is precise. The root ignorance, avidya, is the belief that I am a small, separate, incomplete self. From that belief comes kama, desire, the endless reaching for the next thing that will finally make me whole. Consumer culture is simply avidya with a marketing budget. It needs us to feel incomplete, because the incomplete keep buying. The privileged person without gratitude and the deprived person told to be grateful are caught in the same trap from opposite ends. Both are taught that wholeness lives in objects: having them, or making peace with not having them. Vedanta says neither. The Self, atman, is purna, already full. Nothing added completes it; nothing taken diminishes it.

Real gratitude, then, is not a thank-you to the universe for my stuff. It is recognition. When I see that I am not separate, I see that nothing I have was ever only mine. Gratitude becomes a way of seeing the whole.

The body keeps the ledger

This is not only philosophy. The sense of never-enough lives in tissue. A nervous system trained to scan for what is missing stays in low-grade sympathetic arousal: shallow breath, tight jaw, a gut that never fully rests. We call it stress. The body calls it threat. Traditional Chinese Medicine offers a useful map. Constant striving and overthinking injure the Spleen, which governs digestion of food and of experience alike, and leaves us bloated, foggy and tired. Frustrated wanting stagnates Liver qi: irritability, tension in the ribs and shoulders, headaches, the clenched feeling of a life pushing against itself. And when the Heart’s shen has no settled home, sleep frays and joy turns thin.

In fascia, too, chronic bracing becomes structure. The shoulders that rise toward the ears in a year of doom-scrolling do not simply drop because we wrote three things in a gratitude journal. Contentment has to be felt, practised and allowed to reorganise the body from the inside out.

The ailments of our time are, in part, the body’s honest report on a culture of lack.

Kapwa: the self that includes the other

I carry many lineages in my body. My father is from the American South, from Oklahoma, a descendant of enslaved people, with First Nations blood as well. My mother’s family is from Laguna, and her Chinese ancestors were once persecuted so badly that they fled their country by boat and landed in the Philippines. Some of my people were stolen from their land; some were pushed off it; some had to cross the sea to survive. I know in my bones that one person’s privilege is often another’s inheritance of loss.

I have moved between cities, countries and continents (Oceania is the only one I have never called home). The contrast never stops teaching me. In the Philippines I have watched people with very little share what they have with an ease that still humbles me. Then I come home to Vienna, to a city that works beautifully, and hear people in comfortable apartments describe a hunger they cannot name.

I do not want to romanticise poverty. Scarcity is not spiritual; it is a policy outcome, and much of it was built by colonial extraction. But I do notice what Filipino psychology calls kapwa: the shared self, the recognition that I and the other are not two. Hindi ibang tao, not another person.

Kapwa is Advaita lived at the scale of a barangay (borough). It is gratitude that does not stop at the self. When your sense of who you are already includes your neighbour, you cannot feel grateful for your plenty without also feeling responsible for her lack. The two become one movement.

Gratitude as responsibility

So what do we practise instead of forced positivity? A few things I return to, on the mat and off it:

  1. Trace one thing back. Pick an object you used today and follow its chain: who grew, mined, sewed or shipped it. Let gratitude include their names, and their working conditions.
  2. Breathe into enough. Five minutes of slow exhalation, longer out than in. Let the body feel what it is like to not be reaching. Santosha begins in the vagus nerve.
  3. Notice the reach. When the urge to buy, scroll or achieve arises, pause and ask: what lack am I trying to fill? Inquiry, not judgement.
  4. Turn thanks into action. Let gratitude cost you something: time, money, attention, a seat you give up. Gratitude that never moves outward is just comfort admiring itself.
  5. Refuse to demand gratitude from others. Especially from those with less.

Privilege is not a sin, and gratitude is not a cure. But privilege seen clearly, held in a body that knows enough, and turned toward the other, becomes something else: seva. Service. The natural motion of a self that has remembered it was never separate.

The ailments of today are real. Some need medicine, policy and justice, not a breathing exercise. But some of them are asking us a simple question: what would it feel like to already be full, and to let that fullness overflow?